THE BOTTOM LINE: This is a very nice example of a survivor that had multiple stints in extended storage. This car is the real deal and has all the paperwork to back it up. I am the second owner of the car. I purchased it from my next door neighbor on September 14, 2015. He ordered it from a Downtown Pontiac in Pittsburgh on 3/29/1969. And yes, I have the original order. The car is original as original can be. It has the original drivetrain...engine, transmission, drive shaft and rear end. All of it. And ONLY 47,000 original miles. It has all the original sheet metal. It has all the original interior with the exception of the carpet which was just replaced. I have the original owners manual and the original Protect-O-Plate..both of which are still in the original auto owner’s maintenance folio pouch! It is verified by Pontiac Historical Society (PHS). I have that paperwork and most of the maintenance paperwork done since it was new.
THE HISTORY: My neighbor ordered the car on 3/26/1969 when he was 22 and had just started his first real job after graduating college in December of 1968. He ordered it in its current color of Midnight Green with Green interior with a black convertible top. He paid $4,313.25 for it. For what it’s worth he traded in a 1967 GTO 2 door hardtop! The car was finished on 4/23/1969 and ready to ship to the dealer on 5/18/1969. This car was one of 4,385 convertible automatics built in 1969.
The car was ordered with the following options:
Midnight Green Metallic
Green Interior - Trim Code 256
Turbo Hydromatic transmission
SAFE-T-Track differential-HD
Radio-push button
Speaker - rear seat
Headlamp covers - retractable
Rally II wheels
Steering Wheel - custom sport
Console
Clock-electric
Power steering
Front Disk brakes
Soft Ray Glass - All Windows
Timeline:
The car stayed in Pittsburgh for the first few years.
On November 24, 1969, he took it back to dealer to have the drivers side door handle adjusted. The car had 8,160 miles.
On April 8, 1970, he took it back to dealer for rough start in cold. They replaced the points and cleaned choke and also did annual safety inspection. The car had 12,209 miles.
On October 8th, 1970, he took it in for annual safety inspection. The car had 18,327 miles.
On May 1, 1972 he drove the GTO to Virgina as he was moving to start a new job. He broke down in Maryland and had to have the waterpump replaced.
Within a week of moving to Virginia, someone jacked up the front of the car and stole the front two wheels. They put cinder blocks under the fends to hold the car up and damaged the lower fenders.
On May 15, 1972 he had locking lugnuts installed on the car and it had 25,015 miles on it.
On August 17, 1972, he had the damage repaired on the lower fenders repaired.
On September 15, 1972, he took it to Haley Pontiac in Richmond, Virginia to have the shifter linkage adjusted. The car was recorded with 27,504 miles.
On December 29, 1972 he took it back to Hyman as the engine was running rough. They adjusted the timing and recorded the car with 29,028 miles.
He bought another car as he didn’t want to drive the GTO as much.
On February 17, 1973 he took it back to the dealer to have mirrors looked at. It had 29,560 miles.
On March 8, 1973, Hyman Pontiac properly repaired and repainted the front fenders.
On April 3, 1973, Hyman Pontiac put tires on the car. It had 30,192 miles.
On April 18, 1973, Hyman Pontiac performed a tune up with new plugs and wires. It had 30,369 miles.
On November 7, 1973, Hyman serviced the car. It had 32,559 miles on it.
Then in late 1973 with the fuel crisis at its peak, he was transferred to Chicago. Given the high prices of gas, he decided to drive it back to Pittsburgh and park it at his mothers. And it sat there for the next 3 years until the summer of 1976. On a visit home to visit his family, he started up the car and drove it to Chicago.
The car stayed in Chicago with him until late 1991 when he put it back into storage at his mother’s house. He purchased some maintenance things for it in September 1992.
On February 5, 1994, he finally transferred the title back to Pennsylvania and the car had 41,794 miles.So he had only put 9,000 miles on it while he was in Chicago for 20 years.
In early 1995, he made the decision to pull it out of storage. In doing so, he bought several items from Year One.
On October 4, 1995 he dropped the car off to have two dents repaired in the rear fender.
On August 25, 2005 after the car sitting for “awhile” he sent it to a local garage to have a new master cylinder installed, brake hoses, and hydraulic cylinders for convertible top. The car had 46,180 miles. Only 5,000 miles put on over the past decade.
On June 20, 2006, he ordered vacuum-related items for hideaway headlights.
On November 6, 2006, he had some small maintenance completed. Mileage is noted at 46,210. 30 miles driven since 8/25/05 service.
On November 15, 2006, the car was driven 80 miles to Brady’s Bend, Pennsylvania to be stored underground in a climate controlled former-limestone mine. It was parked that day with 46,370 miles.
He did not see the car again until he took me to see it on September 11, 2015.
On September 14th, 2015 he offered to sell me the car as he would love to see it on the road again.
On September 18th, 2015, we made the trip back to Brady’s Bend and brought the car home in an enclosed trailer.
On September 19th, 2015, we drained the gas, changed the fuel filter and the oil and filter and the car started right up.
THE LATEST: Since purchasing the car, we have enjoyed it and have had a lot of fun bringing the little things up to speed. The list includes the following and all date correct pieces were used where possible:
Replaced battery and all appropriate plugs, date-coded wires, rotor cap and points
Replaced the master cylinder, power booster and rubber brake hoses
Replaced water pump, drive belts, and appropriate radiator hoses and clamps
Exhaust was bad so we installed a flowmaster exhaust.
Found and refinished 4 properly date stamped Rally II wheels. They are on car now. I also have the original spare with original tire plus the two original wheels that were on the car when I picked it up. Remember, the front two were stolen early in its life
4 brand new red line tires in the proper size
Rebuilt carburetor
Replaced convertible top and motor. It works as it should
Transmission and rear differential were serviced with new seals and fluid
Replaced carpet
Dropped fuel tanked and cleaned it. Replace tank straps, fuel sending unit, fuel pump and filter